Hi everyone, welcome back.
In this week’s Deep Dive: 5 ways to open a conversation about your pay rise, without apologising first.
Before the Deep Dive, one quick ad…
ADVERT
Master Claude AI (Free Guide)
The professionals pulling ahead aren't working more. They're using Claude.
Our free guide will show you how to:
Configure Claude to be the perfect assistant
Master AI-powered content creation
Transform complex data into actionable strategies
Harness Claude’s full potential
Transform your workflow with AI and stay ahead of the curve with this comprehensive guide to using Claude at work.
QUICK TIP
When you disagree with your boss, say: "I want to make sure you have the full picture before you decide. Can I add something?"
Why it works: It frames your view as information they need, not a challenge to their authority, so it's far easier to hear.
Use it: When a decision is about to be made that you think is wrong.
🔍 DEEP DIVE
5 ways to ask for more money without apologising
"I know cash is tight, but…"
"I realise the timing isn't ideal."
"I don't want to add pressure but..."
You said at least one of these before you got to the number.
The owner can already see the cash position. You don't need to read it back to them.
Then you said the number quickly and moved on.
They said they'd have a think.
You said thank you. You may even have said sorry again.
Then you walked back to your desk feeling relieved it was over, but wondering whether you'd been too soft.
In a smaller company, the apology feels like the sensible thing to do.
But the person deciding hears something else.
They hear that you don't fully believe your own number.
And you only get one go at it.
It isn't only salary on the table. Base, bonus and equity are all settled at one review, and they're hard to reopen.
What's Actually Happening
Asking for more feels like taking something.
When you can see the cash position every month, that feeling gets stronger.
So you reach for the one thing that makes you look less greedy: loyalty.
The apology is a loyalty signal. It says "I'm on your side" before you've asked for anything.
The problem is what it does to the ask.
It frames the request as a problem for the CEO to manage. Psychologists call this framing (how something is introduced shapes how it's judged).
So they respond to the frame. They reassure you about cash. They say "let's look at it after year end."
You leave having talked about their situation, not what you’ve achieved.
The cash position is real. But it's a reason for them to decide the timing. It's not a reason for you to discount the number.
I don't buy that an apology makes you look like a team player. I think it makes you look unsure of your own number.
And nobody negotiates seriously with someone who has already conceded half of it.
What to Do Instead
State the ask first. Then give your rationale. Then stop talking.
The request goes in your first sentence. Everything after it is evidence.
Here are five ways to open the meeting.
1. Lead with the number
"I'm asking for [X] base and [Y] in equity. I'd like to talk you through the rationale."
Then give your rationale in three points: scope, results, market. Nothing else.
It works because the first thing they hear is the ask, not your worry about it.
2. Call the gap what it is
"My package is out of line with the role I now have. I'd like to address that."
It presents the ask as fixing a mismatch, not asking a favour.
3. Put a date on it
"I'd like us to deal with this as part of the year-end review."
You've dealt with timing without apologising for it. The decision about when is theirs, with a deadline attached.
4. Put the whole package on the table
"I'd like to agree base, bonus and equity together. I'm asking for [X] on base."
These are hard to reopen once agreed. Raise them all in this conversation, not one at a time.
5. Make them tell you what's in the way
"I'm asking for [X] from [date]. If the timing is a problem, what would you need to see?"
This deals with "cash is tight" before you've said it for them.
If they do say it, agree the number now and negotiate the start date. Keep the number the same and be flexible on timing.
Whichever opener you choose, say it out loud once before you book the meeting.
If "sorry" or "I know" turns up in the sentence, cut it.
You can still be warm in the room. Thank them for the conversation at the end, once the number has been said.
This email is general communication coaching. It isn’t financial, legal or employment advice, and it doesn’t guarantee any outcome.
BEFORE YOU GO…
If you’re dealing with ongoing work situations where it’s hard to stay clear, hold your position, or be taken seriously, I offer 1:1 coaching.
My work is practical and focused on real conversations, decisions, and day-to-day leadership moments, not theory or motivation.
Thanks for reading.
Until next time,
Kaley

PS. If you have any questions, just reply to this email. I’d love to hear from you!



