Hi everyone, welcome back.
This week’s Deep Dive is about admitting you don't have the answer, why pretending is the bigger risk, and what to say instead.
One quick tip before we get into it:
A QUICK TIP FOR SAYING WHAT NEEDS TO BE SAID
Decide your position before you decide your wording.
Why it works: Clear thinking comes before clear communication.
Use it: Before difficult conversations.
🔍 DEEP DIVE
4 Ways to Say "I Don't Know" Without Losing Authority
Someone asks you a direct question.
You don't have the answer.
And in the half-second before you speak, your brain tells you that admitting it will damage your credibility.
So you reach for something.
A guess dressed up as a fact.
A confident-sounding answer you're not actually sure of.
A long explanation that circles the question without actually answering it.
I think pretending to know is the fastest way to lose a room.
People can feel it.
The slight overconfidence. The answer that doesn't quite make sense.
And once they catch you bluffing, they start quietly checking everything else you say.
What's Actually Happening
You've been taught that authority means having the answer. So when you don't have it, you feel exposed.
But that's not how the people across the table are reading you.
They're not judging you on whether you know.
They're judging you on what you do next.
"I don't know" said with a flinch, followed by overexplaining, sounds like you've been caught out.
"I don't know" said plainly, followed by a clear next step, sounds like someone in control of the situation.
Same three words. Completely different read.
The admission isn't what costs you authority. The scramble afterwards is.
This is why pretending is more damaging than not knowing.
When you bluff, you put a small crack in your credibility that you can't see but other people can.
When you say "I don't know" cleanly, you do the opposite.
You show people you can be trusted with the truth, even when the truth is that you're not sure yet.
I've watched senior leaders gain ground in a meeting by admitting they didn't have an answer.
Because what followed was so calm and so clear that the not-knowing barely registered.
What to Do Instead
The skill isn't avoiding "I don't know."
It's controlling what comes after it.
Here are four ways to do that.
1. Name it and commit to a time
Don't leave the gap open.
Close it with a deadline.
"I don't have that answer yet. I'll come back to you by the end of today."
This tells the room you're not dodging. You're handling it.
2. Separate what you know from what you don't
You almost always know more than the one thing you can't answer.
So lead with that.
"What I can tell you is the campaign is on track. What I can't confirm yet is the final spend. I'll have that by Thursday."
Now you sound informed, not caught out.
3. Flag the edge of your expertise, then still contribute
Not knowing something outside your area isn't a failure. Pretending it's your area is.
"That's not my area of expertise. But based on what I've seen, here's where I'd start."
You've been honest about your limit and added value within it.
4. Turn the gap into a plan
When you genuinely don't know, show how you'd find out.
"I don't know yet. Here's how I'd get to the answer."
That moves the conversation forward instead of stalling on the thing you're missing.
Notice what all four have in common.
None of them apologise.
None of them over-explain.
They state the limit, then move forward.
That movement is the authority. Not the knowing.
The clearest, most senior people I've worked with say "I don't know" more often than anyone, not less.
They've just stopped treating it as a confession.
Next time someone asks you something you can't answer, don't reach for a guess.
Tell them what you know.
Tell them when you'll know the rest.
Not knowing and losing authority are not the same thing.
Don't let your brain keep telling you they are.
ONE CLEAR THOUGHT: A question to help you think more clearly about a real work situation.
What am I avoiding saying, and why?
How this helps: Avoidance often shows up as over-explaining.
BEFORE YOU GO…
If you’re dealing with ongoing work situations where it’s hard to stay clear, hold your position, or be taken seriously, I offer 1:1 coaching.
My work is practical and focused on real conversations, decisions, and day-to-day leadership moments, not theory or motivation.
👉 Learn more, or if you’re ready to start a conversation, book a 45-minute, free consultation here.
Thanks for reading.
Until next time,
Kaley

PS. If you have any questions, just reply to this email. I’d love to hear from you!

